Everyone’s Saying The Same Thing After Lady Gaga’s Comments About Whether Joker II Is A Musical

As the release date for the long-awaited Joker sequel approaches, we’re somehow no closer to working out whether or not the film is a musical.

When the new movie, starring Joaquin Phoenix and Lady Gaga, was first reported back in 2022, it was claimed that it would be a musical, although its cinematographer downplayed this during an interview earlier this year.

Since then, everyone from director Todd Haynes to Joaquin himself has had a go at discussing Joker: Folie À Deux’s musical elements – and whether it’s actually a musical or just a “film with music”.

Ahead of the movie’s Venice Film Festival premiere, Gaga was asked again about the project’s relationship with music.

“The way that we approached music in this film was very special and extremely nuanced,” she explained.

“I wouldn’t necessarily say that this is actually a musical, in a lot of ways it’s very different. The music is used to really give the characters a way to express what they need to say, because the scene and just the dialogue is not enough.”

Now… is it just us… or is that not just exactly what a musical is? Either way, we’re pleased to see we weren’t the only ones confused…

I mean… isn’t that how musicals usually work?

— Michael Sheridan (@SheridanWriter) September 4, 2024what does anyone involved with this movie think a musical actually is?!

— wolfgangg (@wolfygangg) September 4, 2024Musical – a play or movie in which singing and dancing play an essential part.

or in other words “the music is used to really give the characters a way to express what they need to say because the scene and dialogue is just not enough” Gaga

— Laughing Storm (@BlakleyCory) September 4, 2024So it’s… literally exactly the definition of a musical.

— Anika Chapin (@AnikaChapin) September 4, 2024That’s literally what a musical is. Gaga should know better

It feels like they did a bunch of focus groups and the toxic male audience is scared of musicals so they no longer want to focus on the music https://t.co/1BjVpQbRpm

— mark (@mdseeley) September 4, 2024And proceeds to describe a musical. Are they embarrassed of being called a musical ? Is this Oscar campaign technique? Weird. https://t.co/w2SZvohgrZ

— M loves flowers (@somuchhappenin_) September 4, 2024What is this bullshit statement that these people have agreed on? Lady Gaga of all people surely should be aware that that IS what a musical is??? The Lady Gaga who belted Elphie songs during school lunches!!!??? 🙁 https://t.co/DD8O03NO3J

— nnzy (@astnanlof) September 4, 2024Don’t worry, Marge, it’s not a musical. It’s just that the music is used to give the characters a way to express what they need to say when the scene and dialogue are not enough. pic.twitter.com/uDP4FgS36i

— Joe Reid (@joereid) September 4, 2024Joaquin won an Oscar for his performance in the first Joker film, and returns for the sequel alongside new addition Lady Gaga as the iconic Batman villain Harley Quinn.

The film’s cast also includes Zazie Beetz (returning from the first Joker film), Steve Coogan, Brendan Gleeson and Catherine Keener.

Joker: Folie À Deux hits cinemas on Friday 4 October.